Robin Herman | 08:57
The jury awarded $410,000 against a municipality for a bike trail defect. How did you beat the government?
Glenn Herman | 09:07
Glenn Herman won a $410,000 verdict against a municipality for a bike trail defect up in Westchester County. Riders assume you can’t win these cases, but there’s really no reason for that assumption. A claim against a municipality does require things that a claim against private people don’t. First of all, you need prior written notice of the specific defect that caused the accident or the crash. And if a municipality can show that no one had given it written notice of that defect, before the crash, the case is usually over. Usually, but not always, when there’s no prior written notice, the burden shifts to us to prove one of the two exceptions to the prior written notice law. Either the municipality affirmatively created the defect through its own act of negligence, or there was a special use conferred on the municipality for that location. In this case, about a year before our cyclist accident, another cyclist had been injured on the same defect, and the case was brought by that cyclist, the earlier cyclist. So there was actual notice of the defect that was created, written notice, and still the county turned a blind eye and chose not to do anything about the defect until someone else was injured, and in this case, the jury found that the county was at fault and found for our client.